This article was featured in One Story to Read Today, a newsletter where our editors suggested a single reading. AtlanticMonday to Friday. Sign up for it here.
I had a Netflix subscription for 11 years, until a few weeks ago it didn’t occur to me that I could cancel it, or that I wanted to. For most of my adult life, the service has served as something to entertain: firstly, because I was too broken for cable, and then, once Netflix launched its original show and movie firehouse, because everyone seemed to be screaming about it. House of cards Or Stranger Things Or King of the tigers. Prices have risen year after year, but paying for it has felt like the cost of doing business, if that business understands what your friends are talking about in the first round at a happy time.
Then I bought a new television. If you haven’t had it in the last three or four years, as Netflix’s streaming competitors have multiplied and attracted millions of new users, an annoying surprise may be waiting for you. One by one, you’ll need to withdraw all the streaming services you currently pay for, download any apps you need that aren’t preloaded, sort their avatars into the main menu of your new TV, remember your passwords, and slow down. Slowly navigate the onscreen keyboard to the neuter small arrow buttons on the remote control. It’s a rude process, and as it goes on I get even more annoyed with myself. Why am I paying for these things? How much of this thing do I even enjoy?
I didn’t cancel anything at that second, but it was a light-bulb moment that stuck with me as I realized my credit-card statements or shuffled through an app looking for something to watch on TV, trying to make it divine. An acceptable return, say, five or 10 rupees a month. It was a moment when millions of over-subscribed Americans were finally determined, if they hadn’t already. The epidemic has been a boom time for subscriptions; Not only has glamorous streaming services expanded and grown for all kinds of video and audio content, but delivery subscriptions for takeouts, groceries, cleaning supplies, toys, supplements, raw meats and virtually everything else have swelled their customer base. The same is true of some publications AtlanticআমাদেরWe’ll love it if you subscribe), subset newsletter and Patrion podcast. No one is sure how many members the average family will carry before it starts snatching and discarding things, but we’re probably going to find out.
The maturity of the subscription market varies from industry to industry, but some of the most well-known segments for these types of services, at least in the United States, have indications of near-ceiling. In streaming video, Netflix has long been an industry standard, but its growth rate has begun to decline, and some analysts believe that there is not much room left in America for finding new eyeballs. Paul Hardart, a marketing professor and director of the entertainment, media and technology program at NYU’s Stern School of Business, mentioned to me that when ViacomCBS recently announced that it was changing its name to go to its subscription streaming platform, Paramount. , Paramount Plus, the company’s stock sank — an indicator, he said, adding that investors weren’t sure how much money was left.
Meanwhile, Amazon Prime already has an estimated 150 million users in the United States – more than half of all adult Americans – and now costs $ 139 a year. Like other subscription services, Prime’s customer base has some general limitations: it can only extend to a segment of the population who can afford it and want to make regular purchases on Amazon. And physical product subscriptions have been declining year after year, as early investors like Blue Apron and Birchbox have struggled to hold on to their beloved customers and gain profits.
According to Robi Kelman Baxter, principal of Peninsula Strategies and author of two books on the subscription business, the subscription model has expanded across the market for the same reason over the past decade. Online shopping makes people insensitive to give their credit card numbers. The software that businesses employ to create and manage subscription programs is widely available and easy to use. People who have had a good experience with ubiquitous subscription services – Netflix or Spotify or Amazon Prime – will usually be more open to try more. But the most important reason, Baxter told me, is that subscription services, when run well, are extremely good business. They make customers more loyal and provide stable, predictable revenue and detailed data on how each person behaves. This can make a business not only more stable, but also more attractive for investment.
The downside of the model’s popularity is that it has created a lot of bad subscriptions. “Many boards and executives are now saying, Let’s get some subscription revenueWithout thinking about why it would be good for the customer, “Baxter said. Paying a nominal fee for access to a large content library, bulk discount, gym, or car shares can be a good deal unless you actually use the service, but when The math can be a bit complicated when a business asks customers to pay. For regular delivery of a product: some things go bad quickly or have particularly thin margins and a person needs a monthly box of raw meat or a new type of hard liqueur probably more than a desire to listen to music. Also, try as much as I can, I can’t think of any reasonable case of long-term use for something like Fabletics, which sends people a box of new workout clothes monthly.
Subscription boxes have another notable downside: when you don’t use what you’ve been sent, it accumulates in your home or rots in your fridge, a regular reminder of financial and physical waste. This is how Baxter described that feeling Subscription guilt, And he says it’s one of the three biggest contributors to what he sees as growing fatigue with subscriptions as an idea. The other two will probably sound familiar: the frustration of constantly subscribing to products or services you would rather pay for directly owned or à la carte and the bad behavior by companies that make it difficult for people to sign up or unsubscribe. These responses don’t just affect the businesses that excite them, Baxter said. They can cast a pal on the model as a whole, which affects people’s willingness to engage in different products that share the same price structure. The worse the subscription, the harder it is to sell new subscriptions.
The downturn in a consumer-subscription boom has also created price problems. Many of the most popular subscription services started their lives as start-ups, which meant that investors flooded in with their cash in the hope that they would gain customers as soon as possible. Typically, services offer a few months free service or product to anyone who charges a nominal fee or signs up, without losing money at hand. Theoretically, this would allow them to build economies of scale, bring in a little cash from many people and reduce the per-unit cost of what they are offering. In most cases, though, it just didn’t work out. Prices go up a lot, businesses lose a lot of customers, or both. Even in 2016, when food-kit subscriptions were the new great thing, companies selling them lost as much as 90 percent of their customers in six months, once the steep discount expired. (Unfortunately for subscribers, even the most successful subscription services tend to turn out to be worse deals over time, long after they become profitable: Netflix, which cost ড 8 per month when I became a subscriber in 2011, recently increased its price for the fifth time in seven years. Amazon Prime recently announced a rate hike for American customers.)
The stage we are at now can best be described as a subscription shakeout. The more the market becomes overcrowded with such services, the more buyers will be completely annoyed with the idea, and the investors will get tired of waiting for profit in the end. At that point, there are a few common options on the table: Some businesses will close completely. Others will look for more funds to enable them to lose more money to gain new customers in the hope of reaching a sustainable scale. Others will go the traditional retail route, leaving their products on the shelves in big-box or grocery stores looking for more income, no subscription required. Those with a stronger name could sell shares of the equity to an existing company, as did Birchbox Walgreens, which allowed the pharmacy chain to build birchbox displays of brand-approved beauty products in some of its stores. Prior to this stage, some high-profile subscription services were cashed out, as Dollar Shave Club did in 2016 when Unilever acquired the company for। 1 billion. It is now considered a form of fabrication.
Both Baxter and Hardart believe that such initiatives are for the future of many subscription services, even if the new owners maintain and continue the subscription aspect লাভ profitability is easier if you suddenly gain access to a huge pool of existing customers and logistical operations already serving them. For example, food kit boxes may be appropriate as part of an existing grocery business, where in-store customers can purchase kits and key companies with fresh-food distribution channels can absorb the costly assembly supplies. Many in the streaming industry also hope that the business is moving towards an era of greater integration — perhaps Disney and Netflix will take small services as a quick way to expand their own content library, or maybe Amazon will add Peloton’s On. Claim a workout in the library of streaming options that come with the Prime subscription.
The biggest players in their industry, though, probably don’t need to worry too much. Once millions of people mistakenly call your service a utility, there are many things you can do before they reshuffle their lives to avoid paying for it. No one ever did Likes A mere company, but it took a complete revolution in technology to destabilize the business, which, though smaller than before, remains largely profitable. Meanwhile, I still haven’t pulled the trigger to cancel Netflix, although I realize I haven’t seen it in a few weeks at a time. I still want to see Love is blind Reunion, which will not be available until Friday. And then I want to see the new season Drive to survive, Which comes out in a few weeks. This, according to Hardart, makes subscriptions such a good business. Once a company gets you as a customer, the easiest, most friction-free thing is to continue subscribing. As long as it gives you EnoughYou’re probably not going anywhere.